▴ MENU/TOP
CUB logo

My Experience Switching to an Electric Heat Pump

The author’s new electric heat pump

As the energy sector is making strides toward an emissions-free future, CUB is actively participating in several regulatory proceedings to find out the best possible way to make this transition. As a member of CUB staff, I have worked on these proceedings and heard from both utilities and regulators about what this transition might look like.

Building electrification is considered vital in a clean energy world. It essentially means heating and cooling your home using electric heat pumps. I recently replaced my old gas furnace and central air conditioner with a ducted electric heat pump and decided to share my experience here on the CUB Blog.

Electric heat pumps work differently than gas furnaces. While a gas furnace burns natural gas to generate heat, an electric heat pump transfers heat from the outdoor air to indoors. There are also geothermal heat pumps available on the market that transfer heat indoors from the ground outside, but these are less common and more expensive.

Heat pumps can be ducted or ductless. They can be used to both heat and cool homes. Under ideal climatic conditions, a heat pump’s efficiency can be as high as 300 percent, whereas a gas furnace can be 95-96 percent efficient at best. This means that heat pumps use significantly less energy compared to a gas furnace.

When I began researching heat pumps, I found that there are several kinds of electric heat pumps available (for example, single-speed vs. variable speed) with varying costs and capacities to heat homes. Equipment and installation prices ranged accordingly from around $7,000 to $10,000. No matter the heat pump manufacturer or model, the price quotes from contractors inevitably included a backup gas furnace. Excluding a new gas furnace did not have a significant impact on the final price of the product. Ultimately, I purchased a “dual fuel system” with an electric heat pump and an 80 percent efficient gas furnace.

How would I rate the heat pump on performance? I saw an immediate change in the way I felt indoors. There are no blasting noises from the air vents anymore. It feels less dry and more comfortable inside the house when the heat pump runs. The heat pump works great in both winter and summer, especially when outside temperatures are mild or moderate, which is typical of western Oregon.

How is the heat pump affecting my energy consumption and bills? I got the heat pump installed in 2021 toward the end of January. I paid about $40 less for my home energy bills from February through May this year compared to 2020 and reduced my home energy consumption by about 7000 kilowatt-hours. This is after going through a few extreme cold weather events and switching to gas heating on those occasions.

I am happy that I made the switch to an electric heat pump. I burn less fossil fuel than before and consume much less energy while heating and cooling my home. I acknowledge that there are some high upfront costs involved in electrifying your home heating/cooling system. Heat pumps may be relatively less effective or more expensive to run during extremely cold weather spells. And they are not accessible to many Oregon residents who live in multi-family housing. Utility companies and regulators must work together to make clean energy resources affordable and accessible for all Oregon customers.

Currently, the Energy Trust of Oregon offers some cash incentives that can aid utility customers in adopting electric heat pumps for their heating and cooling needs. Several utilities in Oregon, both public and private, also offer incentives or discounts to customers who purchase electric heat pumps. If you are looking into purchasing a heat pump, be sure to ask your utility’s customer service department about what programs they have in place for energy efficiency upgrades.

Donate to CUB Today

To keep up with CUB, like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter!

12/15/22  |  9 Comments  |  My Experience Switching to an Electric Heat Pump

Comments
  • 1.Thanks for the post Sudeshna. I'm looking into switching to a heat pump now, but first things first: have your home checked to make sure you have up to date insulation and air leak sealing. This is a good investment in using less and staying comfortable before you change heating units. With proper insulation and sealing you can often downsize the heating / cooling unit you need to buy and save some more money that way.

    Morris Green | July 2021

  • 2.When you get a chance, could you write about installation options?

    We've got a building boom in our small community (no houses under $500,000, so no lower income opportunities at all) which means all the local contractors are sucking down work from that, and also meaning waits of several weeks to months. I'm still waiting (going on year 3) for a job replacing my electrical panel.

    A friend who got the split installation wasn't informed that she'd need an electrician to finalize the installation - that the contractor she got couldn't do that part - and that took quite a long time.

    When solar became a thing we had a nonprofit network bulk purchases and network access to qualified installation providers.

    In a county that hovers above the poverty level (except for the influx of retirees who have big money), access to installation is as much as a limiting factor as expense.

    Kathy B | August 2021

  • 3.Kathy - thanks for your question! We can definitely look at doing a blog post about finding and working with installation services. In the meantime, I can tell you that Energy Trust of Oregon is the best statewide resource we know of to find installers/contractors for energy efficiency upgrades. You can request quotes directly from their website or browse the list of contractors by region. Using the approved contractors (called Energy Trust Trade Allies) can also allow you to get incentives that lower the cost of install. https://www.energytrust.org/residential/

    There’s also a program called Savings Within Reach that helps low-income families get lower cost home repairs. Any Energy Trust Trade Ally will be able to get their customers those benefits but it’s best to ask the contractor to apply for the incentives before starting work. https://www.energytrust.org/incentives/savings-within-reach/

    I hope that helps - good luck!

    Amelia Lamb | August 2021

  • 4.I'm looking at a similar upgrade of switching gas furnace + AC to heat pump + back-up gas furnace. Your article was helpful and I have a few clarifying questions.

    I noticed you mentioned an 80% efficient furnace. Were you offered a high-efficiency option?

    do you have a sense for how often you use your backup furnace instead of the heat pump? I want to know if I would be using the furnace for just the few coldest days of the year or for several months every the winter. I want to know if a higher efficiency furnace is worth it.

    Do you have to manually swap from heat pump to furnace or does your system automatically pick the most efficient? Most professional resources aren't very clear on that.

    Now that you've been through the summer, do you have thoughts about cooling with the heat pump? Is it the same as AC or have you noticed any differences.

    Matt R | December 2021

  • 5.Hi Matt - thanks for your follow-up questions! Sudeshna, the author of this blog, is on an extended family holiday trip right now and won't be able to prepare a response for you until after the holidays. I'll ask her to follow up with you ASAP after her return in January though!

    - Amelia @ Oregon CUB

    Amelia Lamb | December 2021

  • 6.Hi Matt,

    Thanks for your patience. I will try answering your questions to the best of my ability.

    80% efficient furnace: Yes we received quotes for higher efficiency furnace + heat pump. I chose the 80% as it was saving us money and we knew we weren't going to use the furnace as much.

    Backup furnace use- The backup furnace is programmed to turn on if the outside temperature drops below 40 F. You can change this threshold temperature.

    Manual swapping - I do not have to manually swap as I have a smart thermostat installed. I have it programmed already. When temperature drops below 40F, my heating system switches over to gas.

    AC - I did not feel any difference between a central AC and the heat pump during summer time. I like the fact that it feels quieter inside the house with the heat pump and the heating and cooling occurs more evenly throughout the day.

    Hope that helps.

    - Sudeshna @Oregon CUB

    Sudeshna Pal | January 2022

  • 7.Hi Sudeshna,

    Thank you for your post! A heat pump is a big investment, so it's great to read your experience.

    I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on a heat pump with an electric furnace? We are hoping to get off natural gas completely, but I know the electric furnaces can be very expensive to operate.

    Thank you,
    Virginia

    Virginia Brandabur | December 2022

  • 8.Thanks for your article. I’m researching options for and HVAC replacement/ upgrade. We currently have an oil furnace, and thinking about doing the heat pump for heat and AC. But we have no gas line to our house and don’t want a gas furnace. Is a backup furnace a necessary part of the process in Portland? Can the oil furnace be a backup? TIA

    Sally | January 2023

  • 9.Switching to an electric heat pump can offer increased energy efficiency, environmental friendliness, versatility, improved indoor air quality, and lower energy bills.

Comment Form

« Back